The Frugal Fiduciary Blog

Self-directed investing in 401ks: Paternalism or Freedom?

Posted by Greg Carpenter on Jun 19, 2013

Image courtesy of watcharakun at
Read More

Topics: 401(k) Investments, 401k blog, self-directed 401k, 401(k)

The 30 Minute Rule: Self-Directed Investing in Your 401k

Posted by Greg Carpenter on Apr 17, 2013

Image courtesy of samuiblue at

Recently, the New York Times Dealbook ran a piece on bitcoins which featured two of the Frugster’s favorite capitalism characters, Cameron and Tyler Winklevoss (who?), better known by their Zuckerbergian nickname “the Winklevii.” If you’re like me, you might be wondering what a “bitcoin” is. Good question. I’ve spent about an hour on the bitcoins site and I am thoroughly confused. According to, bitcoins are electronic currency with no underlying central authority. Normally, I wouldn’t bother to spend much time discussing what many people think amounts to another Dutch tulip bubble, but for bitcoins, I’ve decided to make an exception in the interest of discussing self-directed investing in 401ks.

In a previous post, you may remember that I offered my two more important tips investors should consider when thinking about 401k fees and investments:

1. Do your research on each investment option before you invest
2. Never invest in something you don’t understand.

Well, thanks to the current curiosity and media attention over bitcoins, I’ve decided to add a frugal corollary to Rule #2. The Frugster calls it the 30 Minute Investment Cap, and unlike bitcoins, it’s a very easy rule to understand:

Never invest in something you don’t understand after 30 minutes of research.

I’m not saying that all your research be completed in 30 minutes - I’m saying just to get an understanding of what you are buying. If you have to spend more than 30 minutes I would humbly suggest that it is not the right investment for you. There are a many gray areas in life, but when it comes to most important investment decisions, I like clarity and transparency. If you have a 401k plan with self-directed investing, you must know what you are investing in without a trace of confusion. A few minutes of research and/or explanation from a trusted source or advisor should yield a basic understanding. More than that? You’d best consider walking away.

Read More

Topics: retirement plans, 401(k) Investments, 401k blog, self-directed 401k, 401(k)

How and When to Offer Your Employees Self-Directed 401k Investments

Posted by Greg Carpenter on Feb 27, 2013

Small business owners have a lot on their plates. Offering a 401k plan to employees is just one of many things they must consider doing when attempting to attract and retain talent. But many companies have employees of all ages, investment knowledge and risk tolerance. How to make the best choice for all? I believe offering a self-directed brokerage investment option in your 401k plan can keep your savvy employees happy without confusing your less experienced people.

Read More

Topics: 401(k) Investments, 401k blog, self-directed 401k, 401k participants

Subscribe to Email Updates


“We want you and your employees to have a successful plan.” Greg Carpenter, CEO of Employee Fiduciary, explains how low fees help keep your money in the market, working for you.

Request a Proposal